Alright so, this is one of the longer journal entries I have made, but I promise you it is completely worth the read if you have the time.
Have you ever had someone say something to you that completely changed the way you saw yourself or the world, or it freed you from some attitude you had, and the person didn’t even intend for it to do that, but what they did accomplished that anyway?
Yeah, that happened today. And it was my private classical piano teacher.
I walked into my lesson, exchanged “greetings” with my teacher, and sat down at the piano. “I thought you played very well at seminar last week, Aaron.”
Thinking back to seminar last week… oh boy. Yikes. Seminar is the time of week where push comes to shove with piano lessons. Seminar is where you play what you’ve been working on in your private lesson for a bunch of other piano students. Luckily for me, I got over my sense of stage fright long ago in high school… or so I thought, until the first day I had to play at seminar. Last week, I played a Chopin Etude (Op. 10 No. 3 for all you classical music junkies) that I’d been working on since last summer… or at least I attempted to play it. If you’ve never heard it, it basically has ABA (exposition, development, recapitulation) form, where the A part is very smooth, legato, lush, beautiful, singing melody, etc.; the B section is faster and definitely technically harder. It has this subsection about 7 or 8 measures long that’s just a sequence of diminished 7ths in both hands, ascending and descending all over the place. It is so difficult and fast and demanding and treacherous, that if you miss one note in it you’ve lost the whole thing–there’s no way to recover. So, guess what I did? The piece was going just beautifully–all the way through the A theme, and even into some of the faster, more technically demanding parts of B. When I got to the really hard part… I completely crashed and burned in front of everybody. It wasn’t that I hadn’t practiced it like crazy–I had.
“I think I just got nervous, Dr. Landes,” I said. “It’s like every time I get to that part, I lose my concentration. I know that I can’t lose my concentration or else I’ll lose control. But I get nervous every time and I start thinking ‘oh no, what if I lose my concentration?’ But ironically, the second I think about losing my concentration, I’ve already lost my concentration and the whole piece falls apart.”
My professor replied with this. “It sounds like you just need to trust yourself, Aaron. And trusting yourself is something that you learn. You’ve got to trust that you know the piece. It’s not enough to just know the piece; you’ve got to KNOW that you know it, so that when the part comes up, it doesn’t even phase you. But the question is: do you REALLY know it? Finger memory is NOT knowing the piece. If you’re in the middle of that hard section and one of your fingers slips, you’ve lost it. You’ve got to be able to look at the keyboard and say to yourself, ‘I know where the chord is. It’s right here.’ You’ve got to know that you know it so that in those moments of existential self-doubt, you can say ‘nonsense! I know that I know this piece!’”
I think Dr. Landes said more to me than he meant to when he said this. His words, in effect, freed me of a mental disease that had been plaguing my mind since childhood. Let me explain.
I grew up in what you’d call a pentecostal church. Around me there were always people getting healed, people speaking in tongues, people prophesying, people manifesting demonic spirits and getting delivered, and so on and so forth. Naturally, I just accepted this stuff to be true–what else was I supposed to do? I had no reason to question it. I just believed it.
What I didn’t realize though, is that I really didn’t believe ANYTHING that was going on. I agreed with it, simply because I had no reason to disagree. I knew it simply because I didn’t know anything else. But, even to this day, to employ Dr. Landes’ analogy, it was all finger memory to me–I only knew it because I had been around it so much. Basically, I “knew that I knew” that it was all real, or at least I told myself that, but I didn’t actually KNOW that it was real! (If that makes any sense.) It never sunk into me at the heart level.
This wave of unsureness about what I believe has became all the more apparent to me in college now, as I’ve tried to take a stand for things I believe about God and found that I don’t really know how to explain them to people. Why? Well, the Bible says that out of the heart the mouth speaks. When I try to speak about God to other people that don’t believe what I’d been brought up to believe, I find that I have no words to say because I search my heart and all I find is a lot of confusion about what I actually believe myself. So, naturally, I resort to what I’ve heard about God, what other people tell me, and I try in a messy, jumbled effort to pass this lifeless head knowledge along to the unfortunate listener.
On example is when I try to tell people about the awesome stuff God does at Soldiers of Light church. When I’m trying to explain it to someone who doesn’t understand it (which may or may not be you–just warning you), more often than not I find myself tongue-tied because I can’t escape my own fear that what goes on there is freaky, scary, and fake.
Traditionally, I haven’t been able to bring up any of my doubts about spiritual things because I’ve been afraid of being labeled as a “doubter” or a “heretic” or somehow being excluded from the group. Whenever I try to tell other people about the things I believe, I always find myself unable to speak, and here’s why. I have to be extremely careful of what I say, because I have to make sure everything that I say is true and jibes with what everyone else around me believes. I used to be afraid that if I ever spoke from my heart, I’d say something that didn’t agree with the Bible, and I’d be written off as “one of those Christians who has deficient doctrines or heretical beliefs.” So anytime I would pray with a group of people, I’d never every pray from my heart–I’d always pray from my head because I had to use words and beliefs and doctrines that I knew other people would agree with.
What’s also been a struggle for me is seeing the stuff I’ve grown up with take place, and knowing that it’s real, but not believing it. Let me explain. I went to Soldiers of Light church the first weekend of school here, back in August. Pastor Tony prophesied over me–if you don’t know what that means, it means that God told him some stuff about me and he just passed along the message. Some of the stuff was what is called a “word of knowledge,” meaning that God revealed to Pastor Tony things that were already true in my life and I knew about, but Tony would only have known them had he spoken to me beforehand about them, which he didn’t. For example, a few things the Lord told Tony that night were that I play drums, I work with youth, and I travel–these are all true. I’ve played drums for 10 years, I’ve been involved with leading worship for youth for the last couple years, and I’ve been traveling over the last couple years also to minister musically and spiritually to youth at camps and conferences. The fact that he knew all this without me or anyone else telling him is a big reason for me to believe that he’s not making it up, that what he’s doing is really true. He then went on to the more prophetic part of his message, which means that he told me things about myself that I didn’t know at that time. A few things he said to me were, “you’re going to travel, but you will be more prepared,” “you’re going to work with youth at a greater level,” and “someone’s about to be your partner.” (See bottom of this entry if you want to find out whether these prophetic words are being fulfilled or not.) All this is reason for me to believe that it’s real and that God really does this stuff. But for some reason, I feel this immense sense of fear and doubt whenever I try to tell anyone about it. Some people might say, “that’s the devil,” but in this case I really feel like it’s because I believe it in my head, but not my heart. To be honest, I’m not even sure whether I fully understand the difference between head knowledge and heart knowledge yet.
Lately this conflict with what I say I believe and what I really believe has been surfacing in a way that has been bringing me down in an unhealthy way. Ever since I got to college, I’ve really been desiring to have the ability to speak prophetic words to people, and have them be correct and significantly affect their lives. I’ve also been desiring to lay hands on the sick and debilitated and see them recover on the spot. I’d like to say that I believe this stuff can happen, but honestly, I don’t. In my head I do, because I don’t want to be seen by my Christian peers as a “doubter.” But in reality, when I see someone get healed of a sinus infection or neck injury right before my eyes, (both of which have happened during the last two months), and I’m afraid to tell people about what happened, now I see that this is a big fat red flag to me, signaling that even though I saw it happen with my very own eyes, I didn’t accept it in my heart. Same with prophecy–since I’ve been around it for so long, and I’ve been prophesied to several times, by friends, pastors, and famous men and women of God, I’ve never really asked myself if I really believed that it’s legit–I just passively OK’ed it, and swept any subconscious doubt I had under the rug, to avoid the fear of confrontation.
Here’s the worst part about doing this: it’s caused me to contrive spiritual things and tell myself that they’re from God because I was afraid of failing. To be more precise, when I was like 12 or so, I wanted to be filled with the Holy Spirit and speak in tongues. But I didn’t really want to; I just wanted it because it was what my friends were doing and maybe I wanted to impress them or impress my parents or something… actually I don’t really know. So when someone laid his hands on me and prayed for me, and told me “if you start hearing any strange sounds just let them out,” I started making them up because I didn’t want to be the one kid who didn’t get filled with the Holy Spirit. To be completely honest, even right now as I’m typing this, I’m not 100% sure that I do speak in tongues… I might still be making it up. But I’m happy to do whatever it takes to defeat that unbelief and get to a point where I believe in my heart that speaking in tongues really is legit, even though it sounds weird, because I’ve seen people who speak in tongues, and what they do–I’ve seen broken bones healed, I’ve seen lame people in wheelchairs get up and walk. That’s one thing that I believe in my heart, based on the things I’ve witnessed: God CAN do miracles, even today. But I have a hard time believing in my heart that I personally can do these things. Unfortunately, I’ve been too afraid to admit this in the presence of other Christians who believe it…
…and it’s killing me.
Now as I try to prophesy to other people, I get this wave of doubt every time–what if what I have to say to this person isn’t really true, or from God, what if it’s just me making it up? What if I lay hands on this person and pray for them, and they DON’T recover; what will they think of me then? These are the doubts that I have swept under the rug coming out. They’re under the rug because I’m afraid of bringing them up before my Christian peers. But now I realize what’s really going on: when I try to prophesy, it’s all “finger memory,” because I’ve been around it so long and gone through the motions so many times that I just expect it to come out perfectly, the same way I expected that hard section of the Chopin Etude to come out perfectly. The reason why neither of these things happened is that I didn’t really KNOW either of them. I didn’t know that Chopin Etude by heart, and I didn’t believe in my heart that prophecy is legit, even though I believe the things that have been prophesied over me by other people. Does that make sense?
It’s kind of like this. I have listened to the recording of that Chopin Etude in E Major probably a million times. I have heard my teacher pull it off. I have heard other people pull it off. I don’t doubt that it can be done. What I DO doubt is that I can do it. And no matter how much I tell myself that I can do it, and maybe even believe in my head that I can, the truth always comes out when I get to that part of the piece in front of an audience–I can’t do it, I always mess up. Because I don’t KNOW the piece!
Aha, now I see it. There is a distinct difference between wishful thinking and true belief. What’s the difference? Well, in one, God is involved, and in the other, He’s not.
I met with my spiritual life assistant (SLA), Stephen, this evening. We were talking about Revelation and the end times and we got on the subject of the rapture. Stephen noted how one pastor he had heard said something to the effect of, “I’m not trying to change your beliefs or change the Bible or doctrine or anything–all I’m saying is that I don’t see evidence in the Bible that there will be a rapture in the sense that we will be snatched from the Earth–to me, the “rapture” seems more like Jesus coming to Earth and making it new again.”
I don’t know whether this view is right or wrong. I haven’t read the Bible enough to where I’d be able to apply it to this argument. But I do know that there’s either going to be a rapture, or there isn’t. Both cannot be true at the same time. And so there are two choices I can make: 1) find out which one is true, and then preach that the other one is false, because if I pretended that they’re both true and was okay with that, I would lose my mind; or, 2) sweep one of these teachings “under the rug” and pretend I never heard it. This obviously is not a very effective way to go about searching for truth. But frankly it’s what I’ve been doing with counterarguments to my faith for as long as I’ve been alive.
I told Stephen all this stuff, and after we got done chatting, I was walking to the Curb Cafe to get my dose of Starbucks. While I was walking there, something felt different–and I KNOW that I know that I wasn’t making this up or imagining it. I felt like I had been freed from something. I felt refreshed. I felt…I dunno… new. Like something had been lifted off my shoulders. I suddenly felt incredibly happy, incredibly honest, incredibly real. A couple other things that happened on the way there–walking past the Curb Event Center/Maddox Grand Atrium, I looked up and I swear I saw a purple up there on the side of the building. It was like someone was shining a purple light on the windows, but I seriously looked around me, looking for a purple light or any reason I could find to show that it was an actual light. I couldn’t find anything! Last night, I was listening to a man tell me about how he can visually see the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit is purple. I believe that the Holy Spirit is real, but at first I didn’t really believe that he could see what he claimed to see (although I probably would have told him that I did believe it). Now I’m starting to wonder. I looked away, and back; away, and back; hoping that the purple would go away so I knew that it was just my eyes. It wasn’t. No matter how hard I tried to imagine that the purple wasn’t there, it was still there, and there was absolutely no apparent physical reason for it! On my way back from getting coffee, I saw something in the air swirling around me. I’ll try to describe it; it was almost like I saw a wisp of air flit from my left side to my right side, really really fast. Again, I know that this wasn’t my imagination–I SAW it. I’ve heard Pastor Tony talking about how he can see angels. Again, this is a situation where I “believed” him (or rather suppressed my doubts) because I was afraid of not believing in God. But I didn’t truly believe him. Now I might be starting to. I think I might have seen an angel fly around me. One other thing. I am finding it way incredibly easier to socialize with people! I’ve been praying that God would remove all the walls of social isolation that I built up around myself during homeschool, and I can see that He’s finally starting to answer my prayer. I always find it hard to initiate small talk–it’s flowing out of me naturally now, for some reason.
I don’t know what all of this means. All I’m trying to say is that whatever my piano teacher said to me this afternoon, I believe (in my heart!) that God used it to teach me about the difference between telling myself I believe something and really believing it. Something I’ve been needing to come to terms with for a very, very long time.
I used to wonder why it was so easy for me to believe in God, and so hard for my friends to do so. What I realize now is that I never really believed in God, I just told myself that I did, in order to avoid conflict with my family and people at my church. I think that in order to truly believe something in your heart, you’ve got to have that belief challenged, and although you may have legitimate doubt, you’ve got to overcome it without running away from it. It’s sort of the way your body handles viruses; once a certain type passes through your body, you become immune to it and that particular virus never can come back. Once a certain objection to your belief enters your brain, challenges you for a little while, but you finally overcome it, it can’t come back and plague you anymore. I think head knowledge might be a gift that God has granted to us so that while we are in the process of doubting things in our hearts, we may not lose hold of them completely. I might be wrong about that…but that’s where I’m at right now.
To all my Christian brothers, sisters, fathers, and mothers: please don’t be freaked out if I question beliefs that I once appeared to believe. All I am doing is seeking to safely store them in my heart instead of just trying to convince myself that I believe them when on the inside I never really did. All I’d ask for is your patience and guidance as I seek to build a strong foundation for my beliefs on the rock of ages: Jesus Christ.
To anyone reading this who hasn’t come to a belief in Christ: my hope is that all this has made sense to you. If not, I’d be more than happy to talk to you about anything you have questions about, and not to “implant my beliefs” in your head by any means–nah, just simply to seek truth. I’m really not judgmental, or self-righteous, or anything like that… I’m just a young man seeking truth like all the rest of us.
“That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved” (Romans 10:9, KJV).
—————————————————————–
*Let me just share some confirmation of this message, so that if you’re skeptical about the whole prophecy thing, you might have more reason to believe it. A few days after Tony spoke this word to me, I got a call from my good friend Sam in North Dakota, who had ministered alongside me at a couple youth camps/conferences. She asked me to be her “prayer PARTNER.” Since the Lord had told me through Pastor Tony that someone was about to be my partner, I both accepted her request and believed even more firmly that what Pastor Tony prophesied was indeed true, directly from God, and not made up. About the youth, I was praying for God to show me where to get involved here with youth, and I miraculously met a youth minister who was praying for God to send him a piano player. Can you say, puzzle pieces? So that’s a fulfillment of that part. About the traveling, I’ve been approached about the possibility of traveling to Panama Beach, FL, over Spring Break ’08 for a mission trip, and as I look at the way God’s been purifying my heart and mind lately, I can see that He’s already begun to prepare me for this. These are all just beginnings of fulfillments of this prophecy that was given to me back in August–there’s more coming and I believe it.
Posted in Uncategorized